Economic Evaluation
This chapter outlines the economic evaluation methodology applied in the project. It is built on the life cycle cost (LCC) analysis approach. According to EN 60300-3-3, life cycle cost analysis is the process of economic analysis to assess the total cost of acquisition, ownership and disposal of a product. This analysis provides important inputs in the decision making process in the product design, development, use and disposal.
Product suppliers can optimise their designs by evaluation of alternatives and by performing trade-off studies. They can evaluate various operating, maintenance and disposal strategies (to assist product users) to optimise life cycle cost (LCC). The LCC analysis can also be effectively applied to evaluate the costs associated with a specific activity, for example, the effects of different maintenance concepts/approaches, to cover a specific part of a product, or to cover only selected phase or phases of a product’s life cycle. The main elements are depicted below.
General LCC cost structure
Simplified economic screening approach
The economic evaluation in Railenergy is based on a simplified LCC approach. In practise, this means a comparison of the new energy technology versus the selected baseline technology based on changes in investment/fixed costs (Δ investment costs) compared with changes in total system energy costs (Δ energy costs) from the estimated saving potentials for each technology.
All other factors are kept equal and changes in other operational and maintenance costs are therefore assumed negligible and thus not calculated. The same LCC approach is also applied within the web-based Railenergy Calculator. The Calculator has been developed previously in the project in order to support management judgements regarding implementation of new technologies or operational measures based on their energy, COCO2 and economic performance.
The key results of this simplified LCC are "Net Present Value" (NPV) for given investment horizons (typically 10-30 years) and actual pay-back time for a given internal rate of return (IRR). In some cases where investment cost data is not available, reverse calculations have been performed calculating maximum affordable investment for a given technology and based on the user’s maximum pay-back time. Inflation rate is not included in this simplified methodology.
Operational background scenarios
In order to perform generic economic evaluations of technologies and their combinations a set of operational background scenarios have been elaborated. This is presented in more detail here
Economic calculations
The influence of energy prices is of course the major driver for any business KPI for energy saving measures. In the analyses average European energy prices (electricity and diesel) are used. For each company and country, the economic framework and incentives will be different and thus influence the actual results of any business case.
The final energy calculations are based on the following business indicators per 200 m of train (in case of onboard measures) or per 100 km of electrified double track (in case of infrastructure measures):
- Investment costs
- Annual saved energy costs (year 1)
- Simple payback time (investment costs divided by saved annual energy costs)
- Net present value over 10 and 20 years (using default assumptions for discount rate and energy price)