Railenergy

Economic Simulations

The economic evaluation in Railenergy is based on a simplified life cycle cost (LCC) approach. In practise, this means a comparison of the new energy technology versus the selected baseline technology based on changes in investment/fixed costs (∆ investment costs) compared with changes in total system energy costs (∆ energy costs) from the estimated saving potentials for each technology. The main cost elements are presented in the figure below.




General LCC cost structure


All other factors are kept equal and changes in other operational and maintenance costs are therefore assumed negligible and thus not calculated. The same LCC approach is also applied within the web-based "Railenergy Calculator" (see www.railenergy.eu). The Calculator has been developed previously in the project in order to support management judgements regarding implementation of new technologies or operational measures based on their energy, CO2 and economic performance. The economic evaluation is based on some basic assumptions:

  • The chosen cost evaluation is a "delta (∆) cost" evaluation which means that the cost of a given new technology is compared with cost existing baseline technology. The only exception are "add on" technologies that does not replace existing technology e.g. energy storage
  • Costs are assessed in a simplified life cycle perspective focussing on investment costs, operational costs and
  • The energy costs and their potential savings derive from the simulated and evaluated energy saving potentials from WP 2.5 (Technology Potential Table)
  • No disposal costs are included as they are too uncertain to predict
  • Other variable costs (e.g. maintenance costs) are neglected
  • The base year for economic evaluation is 2010 and inflation is neglected.

Operational Background Scenarios (OBS)

The operational background scenarios are defined as traffic scenarios that will serve as the background for calculating economic performance in LCC perspective as described above. The operational background scenarios are structured per service type and energy supply type just like the technology potential tables but with an additional layer which represents traffic intensity as this is equally important not the least for infrastructure saving measures.
The elements constituting the operational background scenarios are:

  • Rolling stock default data
  • Infrastructure default data
  • Operational default data (mileage and traffic intensity)
  • Energy default data

In order to compare different energy saving measures the operational background scenarios must be aligned or say normalised.
This is done in the following way:

Normalisation of operational saving measures

The operational saving measures e.g. energy efficient driving are assessed based on the annual mileage of one single rolling stock, normally a multiple unit (EMU or DMU). This annual mileage is defined per service type and energy supply type according to typical use of rolling stock in real operation.

Normalisation of technical saving measures on board the rolling stock

The technical saving measures on board the train e.g. traction components, storage components and smart on board energy management are assessed based on the appropriate installation of components in typical vehicles (multiple units and locos) and then scaled up to a standardised rolling stock of 200 m length. In addition, this rolling stock is assumed operated with an annual mileage of one single rolling stock, normally a multiple unit (EMU or DMU). This annual mileage is defined per service type and energy supply type according to typical use of rolling stock in real operation.

Normalisation of technical saving measures in the infrastructure

The technical saving measures in the electric infrastructure e.g. new substations, storage components or new architectures are assessed based on the appropriate installation of components in standardised networks per service type (from WP 2.2 the UIC/UNIFE TecRec 100_001) and then scaled up to a standardised length of 100 km of double track. In addition, this infrastructure is assumed operated with an annual traffic intensity (low/medium/high) and split up into suburban dedicated track, high speed dedicated track and mixed track for regional, intercity and freight rail services.


OBS Default Input Data

The rolling stock data consists of the following default data:

Per rolling stock
(multiple units or loco/wagons)
Per 200 m of rolling stock
Length [m] Number of multiple units or loco/wagons
Gross weight [t] Gross weight [t]
Number of seats Number of seats
Number of propulsion systems Number of propulsion systems
Number of energy storage devices Number of energy storage devices
Number of transformers Number of transformers

Infrastructure Default Data

The infrastructure data consists of the following default data:

Per standardised service type track Per 100 km of electrified double track
Track length [km]
Number of stops & stations Number of stops & stations
Number of substations Number of substations

Operational Default Data

The operational data consists of the following default data:

Per standardised rolling stock Per 100 km of electrified double track
Annual mileage service type [train-km] Annual mileage service type [train-km]
Annual mileage/tractive unit [train-km] Train passages per hour and direction
Minimum train sets needed for operation Operation hours per day, days per year
Running trains per day and direction Train passages per year per service type
Gross-tonnes km in both directions
Traffic intensity scenarios (low, medium, high

Energy Default Data

The energy data consists of the following default data:

Per service type and energy supply type
Average specific energy consumption (traction energy) [Wh or L/gross tonne km]

Economic Default Data

The following economic default data are used in the operational background scenarios and subsequent economic calculations:

  • Discount rate = 6% (an interval of 2-10% has been considered)
  • Electricity price = 75 €/MWh (an interval of 60-90 €/MWh has been considered)
  • Diesel price = 1 €/Liter (an interval of 0,5-1,2€/Liter has been considered)

The intervals mentioned have been considered for sensitivity analysis but finally one single (average) value was defined to keep it simple.


OBS Output Data

This chapter presents the output data and structure based on the input data.
The following output data is defined:

  • Annual energy saved [MWh]
  • Annual saved energy costs [Euro]
  • Simple payback time [year]
  • Net present value after 10 years – NPV10 [Euro]
  • Net present value after 20 years – NPV20 [Euro]