Strategic Evaluation
Each saving measure (technology or operational measure) should be assessed based on the potential impact on the industry performance. For this reason an overview over the status of development of the energy efficiency technologies is given for each railway segment:
- TRL (Technology Readiness Level – TRL) and availability
- Pro’s and con’s compared to the existing baseline technologies
- Implementation aspects
Scenario description
The technologies assessed in Railenergy will be linked to three different scenarios for each railway segment and depending on the energy price development and the possible future implementation conditions and ambitions. This section provides an introduction to the scenario development as well as a description and discussion of these scenarios. Three alternative strategies for improving energy efficiency of railways (see figure).
Scenario 1: Business as usual
Ambition level for scenario 1: Business as usual. mainly isolated initiatives of forerunner companies for improving energy efficiency, limited degree of communication and knowledge transfer. Average energy efficiency improves until 2020 but the efficiency gains are small and large potentials remain unexploited.
Scenario 2: Additional efforts
Ambition level for scenario 2: Moderate effort and coordination. Railway Undertakings, Infrastructure Managers and System Integrators follow a coordinated approach towards an optimised energy performance and facilitating communication and knowledge transfer. The interfaces between the three main players are much better coordinated than in the business as usual scenario (example: joint implementation of eco driving with taylor made on-board technologies (RU and SI) as well as suitable time slots and buffer times (IM and RU). This results in an improved technological and operational performance and thus allows for the exploitation of a larger efficiency potential.
Scenario 3: Long term integration
Ambition level for scenario 3: Sector wide effort and strong coordination of interfaces between Railway Undertakings, Infrastructure Managers and System Integrators. The Energy Saving Strategies of all relevant stakeholders including EU, national and regional regulative bodies and energy suppliers are coordinated and integrated allowing for the optimum exploitation of efficiency potentials on the system level.