Railenergy

Scope

The scope of the strategic assessment reports is the entire European railway system with its different electrification systems and covering both electric and diesel traction. The voltages covered are >1000V. Rail systems with only 750V are not covered in Railenergy.



Dominant railway electricity supply systems in Europe (Source: Wikipedia)


The time horizon for this strategic assessment is 10 years from 2010 to 2020. It covers technologies and operational measures which can be applied in both new projects as well as for upgrade and refurbishment of existing "heavy" infrastructure and rolling stock (suburban, metro and light rail not covered).
This main report describes all relevant service types for railway operation: Suburban, regional, intercity, freight mainline services as well as high-speed (AC only).

Technologies and measures investigated

The following table gives an overview of all Railenergy technologies and measures covered within this Strategic Assessment Report:


Domain Technologies and measures
Operation Eco-driving Level 1: Driver training
Eco-driving Level 2: Onboard device
Eco-driving Level 3: Fluid traffic management
Infrastructure Reversible DC Substation
Real time energy management
2 x 1.5 kV DC Traction System
Asymmetrical AT system
Parallel substation
Reduced line impedance
Increased line voltage (4kV)
Trackside energy Storage unit
Onboard components On-board energy storage (Supercaps)
Use of waste heat
Onboard traction Superconducting transformers and inductances
Medium frequency energy distribution
Innovative hybrid diesel electric propulsion
Onboard optimisation Converter control technology (applied during vehicle coasting)
Active filtering technology to reduce input passive filter (reactors) losses
Reuse of converters' energy losses
MV loads management
Technologies and measures investigated

Operations

Operational measures investigated covers eco-driving level 1 (driver training), level 2 (onboard device) and level 3 (fluid traffic management). Level 1 is characterised by a low investment cost and complexity which then both increase for level 2 and 3. Eco-driving is the use of an optimised driving style – either for the individual train or the entire network (level 3) – aiming at energy efficient "in-service" operation appropriate for both new and existing lines and operations.

Infrastructure

A number of electric infrastructure technical measures have been investigated. In DC systems, four measures have been investigated:

  • Reversible DC substation is able to recover braking energy back into the upstream electrical network i.e. the public grid; the technology can be applied for new and existing lines.
  • 2 X 1.5 DC traction system use existing or new feeders with a potential different from the overhead catenary line. These feeders are supplied with new converters installed in existing substations.
  • Increased line voltage 4kV is the theoretic investigation of a DC system based on 4kV instead of 3kV. This is not just maximizing current 3kV voltage as this is already done; it is rather a new system which requires then new onboard components etc. The Technical Specifications for Interoperability (TSI) do not allow such new supply systems to be built at present.
  • Trackside storage unit is a line side capacitor bank connected to the DC grid and consisting of double-layer capacitors in parallel and series and a discharging unit. Other technologies such as fly wheels exist but have not been investigated.

For AC systems the following two technical measures have been investigated:

  • Parallel substations (double-side feeding of railway lines) have been investigated for 25kV. Until now single-sided feeding prevails. Energy savings or reduction in investment costs are main projected advantages.
  • Asymmetrical autotransformer (AT) systems have been investigated for 25kV in two main groups: Negative feeder systems (conventional 25kV, 50kV and 75kV) and positive feeder systems (25kV and 50kV positive feeder system). The technology is mainly for new systems.

Finally two technologies cover both AC and DC:

  • Real-time energy management includes the monitoring of power fed in all substations interfacing with (external) power utilities to smoothen peaks and reduce energy and power consumption. It is not the same as "smart grids" but it is close. It can be applied to existing systems.
  • Reduced line impedance of the overhead catenary line (OCL) or railway electric grid is the reduction of losses in the wires.

Onboard saving technologies

The onboard saving technologies are divided into components, traction and optimisation. In total nine technologies are investigated:

  • Onboard energy storage, here super caps and batteries in combination. The elements used for super caps are so called double layer capacitors. Storage systems are applicable for both new and existing systems.
  • Re-use of waste heat for diesel traction is a feasibility study of integration of waste heat driven air conditioning system in a vehicle. The investigation is based on a conventional absorption refrigerator which is not yet adapted for mobile applications.
  • Superconducting transformer is based on High Temperature Superconductor (HTS) traction transformer system replacing conventional transformers in future distributed-power multi-system high-speed passenger trains.
  • Medium frequency transformer concept is founded on the basis of available and emerging power semiconductors. A concept has been developed to maximize the benefit of the standard semiconductor design to be compatible with the large volume traction application.
  • By Innovative hybrid diesel electric propulsion is here meant Permanent Magnet (PM) excited generator for the power ranges: 375-500 kW (peak) for regional DMUs, 540 kW (continuous) for Intercity DMUs.
  • The purpose of the Reduction of vehicle coasting loss technology is to eliminate loss of traction inverter and induction motors due to the magnetizing current during the coasting by means of optimisation of traction software and is relevant for both AC and DC services.
  • Active filtering technology to reduce input passive filter (reactors) losses evaluates the possible reduction of input filter inductor and consequently the weight. This technology is already applied in new vehicles.
  • Reuse of converters' energy loss The energy produced by operation of the power and auxiliary converters, braking rheostat, main transformer and inductors is dissipated in the external ambient by means of the use of cooling fluids such as air, water and oil. The research objective has been to recover part of this waste energy for a possible reuse on the vehicle.
  • Medium voltage (MV) loads management: When the maximum cooling performance are not requested, for example at low speed or during the train stops, fans and pumps can be supplied at reduced frequency or turned off in order to reduce the energy consumption and the environmental impact (noise, dust hoisting, ventilation channels clogging in case of snow).

European Status: Railways & Energy Consumption

The energy consumption of the European railways has not been recorded in detail before 2005. UIC has for some years collected overall energy figures (table 81 of the official UIC statistics) but never outlined a consistent and detailed collection methodology. Starting with the Railenergy data collection in 2005, UIC has today established a detailed database which produces energy and CO2 performance values on an annual basis from the following European railway operating companies or associations (see table below).


ATOC UK DB AG Germany NS Netherlands SNCB/NMBS Belgium
BDZ Bulgaria DSB Denmark NSB Norway SNCF France
CD Czech Republic EVR Estonia ÖBB Austria SZ Slovenia
CFR Calatori Romania FS Italy PKP Poland VEOLIA France
CFR Marfa Romania HZ Croatia RENFE Spain VR Finland
CIE Ireland LDZ Lithuania SBB Switzerland ZSSK Slovakia
CP Portugal MAV Hungary SJ Sweden ZSSK Cargo Slovakia
European railway operating companies/associations which are part of the UIC energy and CO2 performance database


The database contains the overall railway production, the electricity mix, the grid efficiency and possible bio-fuel rate. Furthermore is the detailed specification of the energy consumption (passenger and freight) together with the breakdown into service types, load factors, average distance between stops, average speed, etc.
Due to the complex data needs the database will be further elaborated and completed over the coming years with different levels of data access. The database is used to check and benchmark present energy performance of specific rail services and to put into perspective the simulations performed.

Energy consumption

So far, the UIC energy statistics does not provide a consistent split into different service types except for a few countries, nor does it take into account the split into different electrical power supply systems in countries which have more than one. Therefore, an estimation was performed within the Railenergy project.
Very briefly, the methodology for the creation of an overall statistic for energy consumption can be described as follows:

  • Collection of available data from the UIC statistic. Note that the data is based on different parameters (e.g. ton-kilometres or train-kilometres), and does not always differentiate between service types (e.g. passenger or freight), and does not contain any information about power supply systems.
  • Definition of the input mask for calculation
  • Assumptions (in terms of percentage factors) for all open fields for the traffic volume
  • Assumption of typical train masses and the specific energy consumption [Wh/tkm] per service type
  • Calculation and illustration of results.

Results

Estimated transport volume breakdown:



Estimated split of total European railway production per energy supply type


This results in the following energy consumption:



Estimated split of total European railway energy consumption per energy supply and service type


From the values shown above, the following statements can be made:

  • High speed trains are a relatively minor part of Europe’s railway system in terms of energy consumption.
  • As expected, most of the traffic volume is transported by electric traction.
  • The highest consumption takes places in the 15 kV, 16.7 Hz system, not due to any inefficiency, but thanks to the fact, that the corresponding countries have very intensive rail traffic.
  • 15 kV 16.7 Hz and 3 kV DV together haul about half of Europe’s rail traffic. Both systems are often considered to be out dated (which is certainly not the case for the 15 kV system), but still play an important role and will continue to do so also in future.

Notes to the estimates

High speed trains in Germany are not indicated separately in the available statistic; they are treated as Intercity trains.
The whole freight traffic in UK is missing. No values available from the statistics.
Input data in ES as well as IT and NL are imprecise (only based on train-kilometres).
Diesel consumption is also in GWh/year. Values could be converted to kilogram Diesel fuel by means of the corresponding factor (11.8 kWh / kg Diesel).



Energy consumption disclaimer

All results in this section are only "best estimates". Their only purpose is to give

  • A very rough overview about the overall energy consumption of Europe’s railways on a common basis (with an uncertainty of up to about –20 / +35 %)
  • Show the split into the main power supply systems, with an uncertainty of about +/- 20% based on its individual part)
The accuracy mentioned here is only a "best estimate".