Railenergy

Energy and Procurement Standards

Several important standards for railway energy efficiency performance have been elaborated over the last years to support transparent and consistent definition, reporting, benchmarking and comparisons. In the following the most important reference documents will be presented including links to access or purchase these documents.

UIC/UNIFE Technical Recommendations (TecRec)

A TecRec is a UIC/UNIFE standard of which, the primary field of application will be the European rolling stock domain and its interfaces with other subsystems, and is the preferred solution by both partners for, in particular:

  • Product and interface standards such as standardisation of component interfaces
  • Publication of results of common research programs
  • Acceleration and better influence over the European Standardisation works

Pending the publication of a European standard a TecRec will serve as a common comprehensive standard, approved by UIC and UNIFE and therefore recognised as a voluntary sector standard aimed at speeding up the standardisation process and thereby improving the competitiveness of the European railway system.


The general hierarchy within which a TecRec sits is in order of prevalence:

  • EN elaborated by CEN/CLC
  • TecRec elaborated by UIC and UNIFE
  • Standards elaborated by UIC (leaflets)

Topics for TecRecs are selected according to well defined criteria under the supervision of the joint UIC/UNIFE TecRec management co-ordination group (TMT). The partners will agree on a topic and will seek to develop those that are founded on a solid business case.

The TecRec drafting is either done in projects with joint UIC and UNIFE member participation or in dedicated TecRec working groups. The drafting process is then followed by a technical consultation at expert level and a formal approval stage at management level by both partners.

Once approval has been obtained, the TecRec will be published in the English language and placed on this website for free:
www.tecrec-rail.org

Priorities and resolution of conflicts are provided by a joint high-level TecRec Steering Board.

UIC/UNIFE TecRec 100_001 "Specification and verification of energy consumption for railway rolling stock"

This Technical Recommendation is applicable for the specification and verification of energy consumption of railway rolling stock. The criterion for the energy consumption of rolling stock, as set forth in the present document, is the total net energy consumed – either at pantograph or from the fuel tank – over a predefined service profile, which is either taken from the future operation of the train, or according to a standardised typical profile valid for the specific service category of trains. This will assure results directly comparable or representative for the real operation of the train.

The general purpose of this Technical Recommendation is to provide the framework that will enable to generate comparable energy performance values for trains and locomotives on a common basis and thereby support benchmarking and improvement of the energy efficiency of rail vehicles.

The purpose of this document is not to allow for comparison of energy consumption with other modes of transportation, or even for comparison between diesel and electric traction, as it only deals with the energy consumption of the vehicle itself. For the same reason this document is not suitable for the evaluation of the carbon foot print of the railways transportation system.

Energy is an integral quantity. This means that the cumulated energy is the decisive factor. On the other hand, realistic train operation always has to take place under the constraints of infrastructure and operational requirements. An important part is the defined timetable for the operation over a specified line. This Technical Recommendation incorporates these conditions into a so-called "service profile" for the train.

The energy consumed over such a service profile shall be specified and verified as an input to life cycle cost (LCC) considerations. It can also serve as key documentation for the (future) environmental performance of the train. This requires a well-defined and harmonised methodology for specification and verification of the energy consumption. The selected approach has two steps:

  • Simulation of the energy consumption of the train, for one or several specific train runs over a defined infrastructure under defined conditions.
  • Measurements for the verification of this simulation under the same conditions as the simulation within acceptable tolerances.

Two different sorts of service profiles may be chosen:

  • Individual service profiles based on data from a real railway line, normally one or several lines out of the railway network where the train will be operated.
  • Standardised, typical service profiles if applicable for the following categories for passenger service: Suburban, regional, intercity (inter-regional), high speed and for the following types of freight service: Mainline and shunting.
TecRec 100_001

UIC LEAFLET 330 "RAILWAY SPECIFIC ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORS"

This leaflet contains definitions of six key environmental key performance indicators – or "KPIs’s" – for railway companies (operators, infrastructure managers or integrated companies) as well as explanation on how to produce them. The six indicators are:

  • Energy consumption (traction only)
  • Share of renewable energy (energy mix and bio-diesel)
  • Greenhouse gas emissions (CO2)
  • Local air pollution (PM and NOx)
  • Noise emissions
  • Land take (area)

The chosen indicators serve to compare the environmental performance of railways and other modes of transport, and enable monitoring of rail transport’s share of renewable energy sources, energy consumption, CO2 emissions, air pollution, noise exposure and land take. Due to the strict legislative framework in Europe, several references are made to EU legislation (e.g. for air pollution and noise).

Important system boundaries as well as explanations for data processing are defined for each indicator. Furthermore the reference variables needed to implement the key environmental indicators are specified in detail. The data collection and data quality process is divided into three levels: basic, simple and advanced – enabling all railway companies to set up appropriate systems with environmental indicators to monitor their corporate environmental impact and demonstrate environmental improvements or advantages compared to other modes of transport. It is recommended to gradually improve the data quality according to the principles in this leaflet – for the benefit of the individual railway company as well as that of the international railway community.

Purpose and scope

The main idea behind this leaflet has been to develop a small number of targeted, standardized and effective functional indicators able to be implemented by all railways. A functional indicators measures performance compared to the function the service brings to customers/society: transporting people and goods over a distance. Functional indicators ensure comparability between modes of transport by using the same reference as a denominator: "passenger-km" and "tones-km". The key indicators describe the most relevant environmental impact of daily rail operations (traction including shunting) which can usefully be compared with other modes of transport.

This leaflet, its methodology and chosen system boundaries reflect the fact that each indicator must be applicable for all transport modes in order to be compared. However, the chosen approach in this document does not allow focus to be laid on those sustainable aspects relating to economic and social issues.

leaflet on the UIC web site

UIC LEAFLET 345 "ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR NEW ROLLING STOCK"

The Leaflet addresses all relevant aspects for the integration of environmental aspects into the procurement process: from invitations to tender to evaluating tenders with regard to their environmental performance. It is the aim of this leaflet to contribute to harmonization of the environmental procurement framework in the rail sector. By doing so the process of procurement is to become more efficient, enabling new rolling stock with a sound environmental performance to be procured more cost effectively.

Scope and approach

This leaflet is intended to provide assistance for the procurement of new rolling stock for passenger as well as freight transport. It addresses all relevant aspects in the context of integrating environmental aspects into the procurement process. It adopts a functional approach using performance-related and not solution-related environmental specifications. The recommendations given in this leaflet aim at improving environmental performance focusing on the most crucial issues within the whole life cycle. The key areas of energy consumption, noise emissions, exhaust emissions and materials/recycling/waste are considered. Target values are given for those specifications for which they could be derived from the applicable legislation. For all other quantifiable and measurable specifications no values are defined. Instead, operators should set requirements for performance values in order to assess the environmental performance of new rolling stock under specific conditions and at the same time improve the information bases for the respective specification. It differentiates between mandatory and voluntary specifications and divides them into two groups: environmental performance mainly dependent on design or dependent on operation

There is a clear link between this leaflet and the new UIC/UNIFE TecRec 100_001, as this specification of energy consumption of railway rolling stock is the key issue when setting requirements in the energy domain. Please find more information about this TecRec here (link).

Economic effects

An approach to the evaluation of tenders should integrate assessment of the environmental as well as the economic performance with respect to Life-Cycle-Costs (LCC). A quantitative evaluation of the impact of improving environmental performance showed in many cases an increase in investment costs. A through analysis of economic effects should not focus on initial investment costs only but be based on a LCC perspective and take into account future developments in the legal, political and technological framework conditions. A five-phase model for the evaluation process is proposed.

Target audience

Technical and purchasing experts in particular are identified as the main user groups, but environmental experts will also find valuable information here. The leaflet will help the user to: prioritise environmental aspects for rail vehicles; integrate environmental specifications in invitations to tender in a consistent manner and evaluate tenders in terms of meeting environmental requirements. Although the leaflet is primarily geared towards assisting operators, it is also intended to be useful for engineering and purchasing staff of manufacturers in the supply chain (system integrators, system manufacturers, sub-suppliers, etc).

leaflet on the UIC website