Railenergy

Key Performance Indicators

The following Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) have been defined for the field of energy efficiency:

The indicators are developed to describe energy efficiency of railway systems and have to be treated with caution. When using these indicators it is very important not to focus only on the indicator values themselves but use them as a supplement together with analysis of the total energy consumption values (or savings) compared to the total traffic performed. The KPIs cannot stand alone as they could give misleading results in some cases. For example if the total weight of the rolling stock is reduced or increased through some technical measures the KPI 1 might not reflect this change sufficiently.

Indicators 1-4 are overall system performance indicators whereas indicators 5-7 characterise potentials within this system performance. The indicators have been defined in accordance with the approach of the UIC leaflet 330 "Railway specific environmental performance indicators".

Indicators 1 and 2 are technical indicators where energy consumption is divided with either weight or number of seats. Indicators 3 and 4 are for passenger service only and these are more commercial indicators as they divide either primary or final energy consumption with the actual passenger-kilometres (load factor is included).

It is possible to use "CO2" instead of "energy" in the nominator of KPI 1, 2 and 4 in order to create "CO2 key performance indicators". This is also described in the UIC leaflet 330.
KPI 1 is shown for whereas the others are not displayed in this report due to the scope of the Railenergy project and the dominant influence of electricity production which is not controlled by the railway sector.

The CO2 performance of railway systems is depending on the electricity and diesel supplied as well as the energy efficiency. For electric traction it is possible to reduce the CO2 emissions significantly when changing the sources used for the electricity generation (normally referred to as "energy mix"). For diesel traction it is also possible to reduce CO2 emissions by changing the diesel source from fossil to renewable – even though this is being questioned by environmental experts.

KPI 1 - Final energy consumption per traction effort

Equation
Measurement units kWh (or Wh) / tonne-km (passenger and freight transport, electric traction) or
L (or mL) / tonne-km (passenger and freight transport, diesel traction)
Application Passenger and freight rail operation, electric and diesel traction
Definition of equation elements for passenger rail operation
Final net energy consumption (CC) Final net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system or
Final consumption of diesel measured at the fuelling station within the railway system in [Liter] or [tons]
Traction effort Definition taken from UIC leaflet 330
Gross-tkm worked [tonnes km]:
Total weight transported by each train category according to UIC statistics table 42.
The total weight is declared according to UIC leaflet 410.
In practice:
Traction effort = Total train mass * Total train kilometres tonne-km
Total train mass
  • the service mass of the train including the tractive unit
  • weight of passengers (payload) calculated as:
    Payload = number of passenger * standard weight per passenger
  • number of passenger shall be calculated as follows: Standard load factor (defined in TecRec 100_001) * seat capacity for actual train
Total train kilometres The total distance of in-service operation measured during the chosen time interval; measurement unit [km]

KPI 2 - Final energy consumption per offered transport

Equation
Measurement units kWh (or Wh) / seat-km (passenger transport, electric traction) or
Liter (or mL) / seat-km (passenger transport, diesel traction)
Application Passenger service only, electric and diesel traction
Definition of equation elements
Final net energy consumption (CC) Final net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system or
Final consumption of diesel measured at the fuelling station within the railway system in [Liter] or [tonnes]
Offered transport [seat-km]:
Offered transport = Number of seats * Total train kilometres
Total train kilometres The total distance of in-service operation measured during the chosen time interval; measurement unit [km]

KPI 3 - Primary energy consumption per actual traffic output

Equation
Measurement units kJ / passenger-km (passenger transport, electric and diesel traction) or
kJ / tonne-km (freight transport, electric and diesel traction)
Application Passenger and freight rail operation, electric and diesel traction
Definition of equation elements
Primary energy consumption
Final net energy consumption
Final net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system (see figure) or
Final consumption of diesel measured at the fuelling station within the railway system in [Liter] or [tons]
Efficiency rate of energy production and distribution
Efficiency rate of energy chain from extraction of primary energy to the point of common coupling in case of electric traction, or to the fuelling station in case of diesel traction (see figure 5 in UIC leaflet 330)
Actual traffic output [passenger-km]:
Actual traffic output = Load factor * Offered transport = Load factor * (Number of seats * Total train kilometres)
Offered transport [seat-km]:
Offered transport = Number of seats * Total train kilometres
Total train kilometres The total distance of in-service operation measured during the chosen time interval; measurement unit [km]

KPI 4 - Final energy consumption per actual traffic output

Equation
Measurement units kWh (or Wh) / passenger-km (passenger transport, electric traction) or
Liter / passenger-km (passenger transport, diesel traction)
kWh (or Wh) / tonne-km (freight transport, electric traction) or
Liter / tonne-km (freight transport, diesel traction)
Application Passenger and freight rail operation, electric and diesel traction
Definition of equation elements
Final net energy consumption (CC) Final net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system or
Final consumption of diesel measured at the fuelling station within the railway system in [Liter] or [tonnes]
Actual traffic output [passenger-km]:
Actual traffic output = Load factor * Offered transport = Load factor * (Number of seats * Total train kilometres)
Offered transport [seat-km]:
Offered transport = Number of seats * Total train kilometres
Total train kilometres The total distance of in-service operation measured during the chosen time interval; measurement unit [km]

KPI 5 - Share of energy consumption for parked trains

Equation
Measurement units [%]
Application Passenger rail operation, electric and diesel traction. In most cases for passenger diesel traction, the calculation will include both an amount of diesel consumption ("in service") as well as an amount of electricity consumption ("out of service" or parked trains). In order to compare the different energy sources the following calculation factor has to be applied:
1 Liter of diesel = 2,7 * kWh
Definition of equation elements
Energy consumption of trains in parked mode (CC) Total energy consumption of a given number of trains in parking mode. Three categories are defined in TecRec 100_001:
1) pre-heating/pre-cooling
2) cleaning/maintenance and
3) hibernating
all measured either at the pantograph, at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh] or
Consumption of diesel measured in parked mode in [Liter] or [tonnes]
Final net energy consumption (CC) Final net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system or
Final consumption of diesel measured at the fuelling station within the railway system in [Liter] or [tonnes]

KPI 6 - Energy recuperation rate at pantograph level

Equation
Measurement units [%]
Application Passenger and freight rail operation, electric traction only
Definition of equation elements
Recuperated energy of trains (P) Recuperated energy of trains (used by other trains or fed back into public grid), measured at the pantograph in [kWh] or [MWh]
Final gross energy consumption (CC) Final gross energy consumption measured at the pantograph in [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow into the entire railway system (see figure)

KPI 7 - Efficiency of the railway distribution grid including substations

Equation
Measurement units [%]
Application Passenger and freight rail operation, electric traction only
Definition of equation elements
Final Net energy consumption (CC) Final Net energy consumption measured at the point of common coupling [kWh] or [MWh], defined as inflow minus outflow from the entire railway system (see figure)
Net Energy consumption of trains (P) Net Energy consumption of trains, measured at the pantograph in [kWh] or [MWh]